“WE SIMPLY NEED TO READ AND TO HEAR FROM OTHERS”: DISCUSSING FREE SPEECH AT THE UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW
A big thank you to the University of Glasgow’s Professor Adam Tomkins who joined us and a room full of students and academics last week to discuss his new book on free speech: "On the Law of Speaking Freely".
I wrote about our reasons for wanting to tackle free speech questions last month. Adam’s book is a conscious attempt to rescue the free speech issue from the culture wars and to shed some light on this most contentious of issues. At our event, we talked through current flashpoints around hate speech and offensive speech, and set out the principles that can help guide us through the minefield.
Here are my three takeaways:
1. We need to keep talking about talking
The event showed that the issues around free speech are far from simple. Tomkins described himself as a free speech advocate when introducing himself. But as he explained, that doesn’t mean he thinks anybody should just be able to say anything they like. So yes, as he argues in his book, “counter speech, not criminalisation, will almost always be the most appropriate reaction to hate speech”. But that ‘almost’ demonstrates the challenge. There will, he adds, be “some extreme situations where it may be appropriate to criminalise hate speech”. Though quite how to criminalise is another matter too: at the event, many of us discussed whether criminal hate speech should lead to lengthy prison sentences or to police arresting you as you enter the country (as has happened in recent weeks). At a time when these matters are being tossed into our culture wars, there is a need for universities and other public bodies to keep discussing these dilemmas and questions with openness and clarity, in the hope we can make better decisions. What we’re fundamentally talking about here is how as individuals we rub along as a society. This is too important to be left to a few keyboard warriors.
2. Free speech is good for you
A large part of the evening was taken up by Adam running through the arguments for free speech. He set out three core reasons: firstly, because censorship is worse; secondly because we cannot get to the truth without it; and thirdly because the process of enquiry and growth that comes from cross-examining our attitudes and views leads to individual fulfilment. We took in John Milton, John Stuart Mill and US Supreme Court judge Oliver Wendell Holmes, all of whom feature heavily in the book, who between them set out the case for why free speech makes us better. As Tomkins summarises in his book: “If we are to flourish as individuals, we simply need to read and to hear from others, especially those with whom we disagree or who are telling us things we do not already know”.
“If we are to flourish as individuals, we simply need to read and to hear from others, especially those with whom we disagree or who are telling us things we do not already know."
Adam used a personal example from the Independence Referendum to illustrate the case. Campaigning on the No side of the fence, he recalled a debate with Yes supporters who had better arguments than he. This, he remembered, forced him to go home and come up with a better case. Thus an encounter with the other side helped his own ideas grow. It’s through free speech and the free exchange of ideas and views that we grow and flourish.
3. Listening is also free
Has there ever been quite so much speech as there is today? Thanks to social media everyone today has a public voice. And due to that always-on world we are rarely far away from someone somewhere talking at us. I ended the event by noting that, as well as speaking more, we needed to listen more too. Who knows – it may be that our opponents and critics have something useful to tell us.
Thanks to all those who attended. We’re interested in thoughts on how we keep this conversation going. If anyone has some bright ideas for how we as a University community keep talking about talking, email us at johnsmithcentre@glasgow.ac.uk

Contribute
Share your research & insights with the world—submit your idea to our Research & Insights platform and reach a broader audience.
Submit Your Ideas